Villarreal 0-0 Man Utd Highlights
Manchester United and Villarreal contested their fourth straight goalless draw in the Champions League as both qualified from the group stage.
Cristiano Ronaldo came closest to a goal but Diego Lopez brilliantly tipped his strike on to the crossbar.
The Villarreal keeper also denied Wayne Rooney, Anderson and Darren Fletcher while Joan Capdevila headed a deflected Rooney cross off the line.
Capdevila was later given a red card for a challenge on Ronaldo.
It was a contentious decision and ensured a lively and passionate end to what had been a largely low-key European encounter.